When the founders exited Constitution Hall after completing the Constitution, a member of the crowd outside the hall asked anxciously, "What have you given us?" Of course the answer was anticipated to be some form of democratized monarchy. The concepts of democracy had not yet taken hold in the consciousness or understanding of the average citizen. But as has been learned in a number of ways over the centuries, pure democracy has it's drawbacks. A good explanation of this was made recently by Fred Reed.
"To begin, we have much too much democracy. We need to discourage people from voting. In fact, the gravest obstacle to the restoration of civilization in North America is universal suffrage. Letting everybody vote makes no sense. Obviously they are no good at it. The whole idea smacks of the fumble-witted idealism of a high-school Marxist society. At least eighty percent of the electorate lives in blank medieval darkness regarding any matter of public policy or history. They might as well vote on the incisions needed in cardiac surgery as try to govern themselves. Poll after poll shows that even graduates of America's pathetic...universities, which means most of the universities, do not know who fought in WWI, or within a century when the Civil War took place, or who Galileo was. These are the better informed. The rest barely know what century they live in. Unalloyed ignorance is not an obvious qualification for governing, despite all appearances." --Fred Reed
The Federalist Patriot
www.FederalistPatriot.US
The answer to that citizen outside Constitution Hall was, "A Republic, if you can keep it". Most people think they live in a democracy. In reality, we live in a "democratized republic". We were given a republic, but we have not kept it. One of the original requirements for voting was that you be a land owner. Of course, women were not allowed to vote either, but that is another discussion. The logic behind restricting voting to those who held land was that only those that had a stake in the success of the republic, should have a say in its governance. Today, we have just the opposite. We have people that have no stake, who live off the state and then vote for politicians that will promise even more "goodies" to those who contribute nothing, thus, self perpetuating and even reinforcing the socialistic tendencies of the society.
We didn't keep the republic, and the huge deficits, and eventual collapse, will prove the wisdom of the Founding Fathers, and the error of our ways.
