Liberals have been crying that a job, health care, even a home, is a right. They've been arguing it for years. Below is the best articulation of the philosophy of the Founding Fathers and the accepted view in this country for over a hundred years until people like Wilson, Roosevelt, etc. came into power. But they never argue the point, they just ignore it and pretend it doesn't exist. But if you can't argue the point, how can you maintain your philosophy. If you want to maintain the liberal position (maybe I should say progressive), you have to defeat the logic of the traditional argument for free enterprise and a government based on libertarian principles as articulated by the Founding Fathers in the Constitution, the Federalist Papers, and their own personal writings, speeches and journals. Lots of luck.
From “Man’s Rights,” by Ayn Rand (1963)
Does the principle of individual rights entail the right to a job, a home, or health care? Jobs, food, clothing, recreation (!), homes, medical care, education, etc., do not grow in nature. These are man-made values—goods and services produced by men. Who is to provide them? If some men are entitled by right to the products of the work of others, it means that those others are deprived of rights and condemned to slave labor. Any alleged “right” of one man, which necessitates the violation of the rights of another, is not and cannot be a right. No man can have a right to impose an unchosen obligation, an unrewarded duty or an involuntary servitude on another man. There can be no such thing as “the right to enslave.” (Today we joke about how we work for the government until sometime in March or April - it's not really a funny joke)
A right does not include the material implementation of that right by other men; it includes only the freedom to earn that implementation by one’s own effort. Observe, in this context, the intellectual precision of the Founding Fathers: they spoke of the right to the pursuit of happiness—not of the right to happiness. It means that a man has the right to take the actions he deems necessary to achieve his happiness; it does not mean that others must make him happy.
The right to life means that a man has the right to support his life by his own work (on any economic level, as high as his ability will carry him); it does not mean that others must provide him with the necessities of life. The right to property means that a man has the right to take the economic actions necessary to earn property, to use it and to dispose of it; it does not mean that others must provide him with property. The right of free speech means that a man has the right to express his ideas without danger of suppression, interference or punitive action by the government. It does not mean that others must provide him with a lecture hall, a radio station or a printing press through which to express his ideas.
Any undertaking that involves more than one man, requires the voluntary consent of every participant. Every one of them has the right to make his own decision, but none has the right to force his decision on the others. There is no such thing as “a right to a job”—there is only the right of free trade, that is: a man’s right to take a job if another man chooses to hire him. There is no “right to a home,” only the right of free trade: the right to build a home or to buy it. There are no “rights to a ‘fair’ wage or a ‘fair’ price” if no one chooses to pay it, to hire a man or to buy his product. There are no “rights of consumers” to milk, shoes, movies or champagne if no producers choose to manufacture such items (there is only the right to manufacture them oneself). There are no “rights” of special groups, there are no “rights of farmers, of workers, of businessmen, of employees, of employers, of the old, of the young, of the unborn.” There are only the Rights of Man—rights possessed by every individual man and by all men as individuals.
We have for many years assumed it is ok to agree as a community to come together in the taxing and spending to build roads, hire policemen, deliver mail, etc. Unfortunately, we have allowed the government to move into more and more areas of responsibility (education, health care, retirement, etc.) until now we are nearing the point where some people think government should provide everything they need. In fact, we are one generation from the electorate demanding the government do just that. Problem is, when someone provides you everything you need, you one day wake up and realize you are a slave.
Thursday, June 03, 2010
The Next Great Theft (a.k.a. Bailout)
The following is from the Wall Street Journal - News and Opinion/June 1, 2010.
It details Pennsylvania Democrat Sen. Bob Casey's proposal to bailout the poorly managed union retirement funds. It's not bad enough that they are using our tax dollars to bailout the giant megabanks, the auto companies, and are forcing us into a federalized healthcare system. Now they are going to openly and without shame engage in legalized theft on the part of their constituents, the labor unions. As a former state employee, I'm aware that our retirement fund is currently about 75% funded. We are much better off than many other states. We would be 100% funded if the state hadn't gone about 5 years (if I remember correctly) because at the time we were fully funded. Now that we are behind the state is supposed to make up the difference. As employees we have always paid our full share. The problem with the labor union retirement funds is that the unions have always sought to score big victories and the sound of a 10% pay raise gets more headlines than a 7% pay raise and additional funding of the pension funds.
So, they made their bed, and they want you to lay in it. Sen. Casey says the bailout will cost the taxpayer a mere $8 billion. But Moody's says the pensions are under funded by $165 billion. Open wide. Your wallet that is.
"The Union Pension Bailout”
Feeling tapped out after stimulus, ObamaCare and everything else?
Senator Bob Casey has one more deal for you. If the Pennsylvania
Democrat gets his way, U.S. taxpayers will also pick up the
astonishing tab for poorly managed union pension plans.
Mr. Casey is gathering support for his curiously named "Create Jobs
and Save Benefits Act," a bailout for union-run retirement plans.
Similar to House legislation from North Dakota Democrat Earl Pomeroy
and Ohio Republican Patrick Tiberi, the bill would transfer tens of
billions of dollars worth of retiree liabilities to the Pension
Benefit Guaranty Corporation, i.e., to taxpayers.
At issue are multi-employer pension plans, in which companies across
an industry pay into a single pension pool. The plans are
predominately run by unions and for years have distinguished
themselves by poor management. The Labor Department in 2008 listed 230
multi-employer plans that were either endangered (less than 80%
funded), or critical (less than 65% funded), or that had applied to
government for funding relief. By 2009 that number had soared to 640.
The financial crash is partly to blame, but even before 2006 only
about 6% of multi-employer plans were fully funded, compared to about
31% of single-employer plans. The real problem is that multi-employer
plans have become a sort of pension Ponzi scheme.
Unions love multi-employer plans because they let workers keep their
retirement benefits even if they switch jobs to another participating
company. This encourages lifelong union membership. Unions are less
enthusiastic about paying the bills. The negotiating priority of union
leaders is to get hefty wage increases and benefits for current
workers, leaving the scraps to the pensions of retirees who no longer
vote in union elections.
When a company in an industry goes out of business, meanwhile, the
remaining firms are still on the hook for all costs of the
multi-employer plan. This explains why the trucking industry is
backing Mr. Casey's bill, and why Mr. Casey announced his legislation
at a Pennsylvania facility of YRC Worldwide, a Kansas trucking outfit.
Someone has to pay for years of the industry agreeing to Teamster
demands.
Mr. Casey's bill would cordon off "orphaned" pensions—those for which
an employer has stopped contributing or withdrawn from a
multi-employer fund—and put them into a separate account. Surviving
companies would pay benefits to these orphans for five years, after
which they'd get kicked to the PBGC, which would shoulder the benefits
until the last retiree or beneficiary dies. The remaining
multi-employer plan would be back in the black, free to start the
negative-feedback loop of underpayments and overpromises again.
All of this is a raw deal for union pensioners who worked a lifetime
in expectation of certain benefits. The PBGC's current maximum payment
to any plan participant is $12,800 a year. Mr. Casey's bill raises
that to $21,000 year, still only a fraction of existing pension
promises.
Not that the PBGC has the cash to pay more. The agency's deficit was
$21 billion as of last September, and it is expected to rise to an
estimated $34 billion by 2019. Mr. Casey is claiming his
multi-employer-bailout scheme will cost a mere $8 billion, but Moody's
estimated last year that multi-employer plans were $165 billion
underfunded.
The tab is likely to be much higher given the moral hazard Mr. Casey
would create. As Hudson Institute economist Diana Furchtgott-Roth
notes, the bill creates "a vicious circle. Once PGBC took over some
plans, other employers would want to declare bankruptcy, unload plans
on the PGBC, and reorganize under another name. The incentives to do
this would be enormous."
In 2006 Congress passed the Pension Protection Act to prod companies
and unions to shape up their pension plans, whether by lowering
benefits, increasing contributions from employers and workers, or even
raising retirement ages. The fact that many unions and companies have
refused to use these tools does not make their mistake the obligation
of U.S. taxpayers. If unions really cared about protecting retirees,
they'd ditch defined-benefit plans and adopt 401(k) plans that give
workers control over their retirement assets.
Union chiefs prefer the power that comes with managing huge pension
investments—even if they're failing. They are now counting on Mr.
Casey to preserve their power by making taxpayers pick up the tab for
years of pension mismanagement. With the union priority of "card
check" stalled, word is that the Casey bailout is Big Labor's
consolation prize. Taxpayers should let Congress know they don't want
to pay.
It details Pennsylvania Democrat Sen. Bob Casey's proposal to bailout the poorly managed union retirement funds. It's not bad enough that they are using our tax dollars to bailout the giant megabanks, the auto companies, and are forcing us into a federalized healthcare system. Now they are going to openly and without shame engage in legalized theft on the part of their constituents, the labor unions. As a former state employee, I'm aware that our retirement fund is currently about 75% funded. We are much better off than many other states. We would be 100% funded if the state hadn't gone about 5 years (if I remember correctly) because at the time we were fully funded. Now that we are behind the state is supposed to make up the difference. As employees we have always paid our full share. The problem with the labor union retirement funds is that the unions have always sought to score big victories and the sound of a 10% pay raise gets more headlines than a 7% pay raise and additional funding of the pension funds.
So, they made their bed, and they want you to lay in it. Sen. Casey says the bailout will cost the taxpayer a mere $8 billion. But Moody's says the pensions are under funded by $165 billion. Open wide. Your wallet that is.
"The Union Pension Bailout”
Feeling tapped out after stimulus, ObamaCare and everything else?
Senator Bob Casey has one more deal for you. If the Pennsylvania
Democrat gets his way, U.S. taxpayers will also pick up the
astonishing tab for poorly managed union pension plans.
Mr. Casey is gathering support for his curiously named "Create Jobs
and Save Benefits Act," a bailout for union-run retirement plans.
Similar to House legislation from North Dakota Democrat Earl Pomeroy
and Ohio Republican Patrick Tiberi, the bill would transfer tens of
billions of dollars worth of retiree liabilities to the Pension
Benefit Guaranty Corporation, i.e., to taxpayers.
At issue are multi-employer pension plans, in which companies across
an industry pay into a single pension pool. The plans are
predominately run by unions and for years have distinguished
themselves by poor management. The Labor Department in 2008 listed 230
multi-employer plans that were either endangered (less than 80%
funded), or critical (less than 65% funded), or that had applied to
government for funding relief. By 2009 that number had soared to 640.
The financial crash is partly to blame, but even before 2006 only
about 6% of multi-employer plans were fully funded, compared to about
31% of single-employer plans. The real problem is that multi-employer
plans have become a sort of pension Ponzi scheme.
Unions love multi-employer plans because they let workers keep their
retirement benefits even if they switch jobs to another participating
company. This encourages lifelong union membership. Unions are less
enthusiastic about paying the bills. The negotiating priority of union
leaders is to get hefty wage increases and benefits for current
workers, leaving the scraps to the pensions of retirees who no longer
vote in union elections.
When a company in an industry goes out of business, meanwhile, the
remaining firms are still on the hook for all costs of the
multi-employer plan. This explains why the trucking industry is
backing Mr. Casey's bill, and why Mr. Casey announced his legislation
at a Pennsylvania facility of YRC Worldwide, a Kansas trucking outfit.
Someone has to pay for years of the industry agreeing to Teamster
demands.
Mr. Casey's bill would cordon off "orphaned" pensions—those for which
an employer has stopped contributing or withdrawn from a
multi-employer fund—and put them into a separate account. Surviving
companies would pay benefits to these orphans for five years, after
which they'd get kicked to the PBGC, which would shoulder the benefits
until the last retiree or beneficiary dies. The remaining
multi-employer plan would be back in the black, free to start the
negative-feedback loop of underpayments and overpromises again.
All of this is a raw deal for union pensioners who worked a lifetime
in expectation of certain benefits. The PBGC's current maximum payment
to any plan participant is $12,800 a year. Mr. Casey's bill raises
that to $21,000 year, still only a fraction of existing pension
promises.
Not that the PBGC has the cash to pay more. The agency's deficit was
$21 billion as of last September, and it is expected to rise to an
estimated $34 billion by 2019. Mr. Casey is claiming his
multi-employer-bailout scheme will cost a mere $8 billion, but Moody's
estimated last year that multi-employer plans were $165 billion
underfunded.
The tab is likely to be much higher given the moral hazard Mr. Casey
would create. As Hudson Institute economist Diana Furchtgott-Roth
notes, the bill creates "a vicious circle. Once PGBC took over some
plans, other employers would want to declare bankruptcy, unload plans
on the PGBC, and reorganize under another name. The incentives to do
this would be enormous."
In 2006 Congress passed the Pension Protection Act to prod companies
and unions to shape up their pension plans, whether by lowering
benefits, increasing contributions from employers and workers, or even
raising retirement ages. The fact that many unions and companies have
refused to use these tools does not make their mistake the obligation
of U.S. taxpayers. If unions really cared about protecting retirees,
they'd ditch defined-benefit plans and adopt 401(k) plans that give
workers control over their retirement assets.
Union chiefs prefer the power that comes with managing huge pension
investments—even if they're failing. They are now counting on Mr.
Casey to preserve their power by making taxpayers pick up the tab for
years of pension mismanagement. With the union priority of "card
check" stalled, word is that the Casey bailout is Big Labor's
consolation prize. Taxpayers should let Congress know they don't want
to pay.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
