Liberals have been crying that a job, health care, even a home, is a right. They've been arguing it for years. Below is the best articulation of the philosophy of the Founding Fathers and the accepted view in this country for over a hundred years until people like Wilson, Roosevelt, etc. came into power. But they never argue the point, they just ignore it and pretend it doesn't exist. But if you can't argue the point, how can you maintain your philosophy. If you want to maintain the liberal position (maybe I should say progressive), you have to defeat the logic of the traditional argument for free enterprise and a government based on libertarian principles as articulated by the Founding Fathers in the Constitution, the Federalist Papers, and their own personal writings, speeches and journals. Lots of luck.
From “Man’s Rights,” by Ayn Rand (1963)
Does the principle of individual rights entail the right to a job, a home, or health care? Jobs, food, clothing, recreation (!), homes, medical care, education, etc., do not grow in nature. These are man-made values—goods and services produced by men. Who is to provide them? If some men are entitled by right to the products of the work of others, it means that those others are deprived of rights and condemned to slave labor. Any alleged “right” of one man, which necessitates the violation of the rights of another, is not and cannot be a right. No man can have a right to impose an unchosen obligation, an unrewarded duty or an involuntary servitude on another man. There can be no such thing as “the right to enslave.” (Today we joke about how we work for the government until sometime in March or April - it's not really a funny joke)
A right does not include the material implementation of that right by other men; it includes only the freedom to earn that implementation by one’s own effort. Observe, in this context, the intellectual precision of the Founding Fathers: they spoke of the right to the pursuit of happiness—not of the right to happiness. It means that a man has the right to take the actions he deems necessary to achieve his happiness; it does not mean that others must make him happy.
The right to life means that a man has the right to support his life by his own work (on any economic level, as high as his ability will carry him); it does not mean that others must provide him with the necessities of life. The right to property means that a man has the right to take the economic actions necessary to earn property, to use it and to dispose of it; it does not mean that others must provide him with property. The right of free speech means that a man has the right to express his ideas without danger of suppression, interference or punitive action by the government. It does not mean that others must provide him with a lecture hall, a radio station or a printing press through which to express his ideas.
Any undertaking that involves more than one man, requires the voluntary consent of every participant. Every one of them has the right to make his own decision, but none has the right to force his decision on the others. There is no such thing as “a right to a job”—there is only the right of free trade, that is: a man’s right to take a job if another man chooses to hire him. There is no “right to a home,” only the right of free trade: the right to build a home or to buy it. There are no “rights to a ‘fair’ wage or a ‘fair’ price” if no one chooses to pay it, to hire a man or to buy his product. There are no “rights of consumers” to milk, shoes, movies or champagne if no producers choose to manufacture such items (there is only the right to manufacture them oneself). There are no “rights” of special groups, there are no “rights of farmers, of workers, of businessmen, of employees, of employers, of the old, of the young, of the unborn.” There are only the Rights of Man—rights possessed by every individual man and by all men as individuals.
We have for many years assumed it is ok to agree as a community to come together in the taxing and spending to build roads, hire policemen, deliver mail, etc. Unfortunately, we have allowed the government to move into more and more areas of responsibility (education, health care, retirement, etc.) until now we are nearing the point where some people think government should provide everything they need. In fact, we are one generation from the electorate demanding the government do just that. Problem is, when someone provides you everything you need, you one day wake up and realize you are a slave.
